On January 11th, readers were given the following assignment:
In “Challenge of Youth” (1974), Professor Friedrich Heer documents and analyzes historically-significant youth movements, from the time of ancient Greece through the hippie era, and concludes that:
“[T]he harsh light of historical fact [is] that every significant youth movement is in its own time crushed by the forces in power, and its spirit frequently perverted or bent to other uses[.]”
It is also interesting to note that Professor Heer identifies the common characteristic among all youth movements as being “the symbolic rejection of the father (authority), and frequent adoption of a new ‘father’…” and references Malachi 4:6 (“…turn the hearts of fathers to their children and the hearts of children to their fathers…”) to conclude that “it is the fathers who have the last word.”
As a presuppositionally-Christian youth movement, how do you think the Rebelution differs (or should differ) from the youth movements Professor Heer described?
Rebellion vs. Rebelution by Hannah
Note the question: “As a presuppositionally-Christian youth movement, how do think the Rebelution differs (or should differ) from the youth movements Professor Heer described?”
First of all, I would like to offer you a definition of the word rebellion. My trusty friend, dictionary.com, defines it as either an “open, armed, and organized resistance to a constitued government” or “an act or a show of defiance toward an authority or established convention”.
If the common characteristic between all youth movements is “the symblic rejection of the father (authority), and frequent adoption of a new ‘father’…” then I believe that we should view the latter of the two definitions as fitting in our context.
If, as Professor Heer argues, the youth movements of eras past had a tendency to rebel against and reject the current authority, then the Rebelution should certainly differ from these! While the Rebelution certainly does go against the grain of our society’s slacker/entitlement view of things, I do not believe that the the Rebelution rebels in the way that the dictionary or Professor Heer define it.
The Rebelution shares the characteristic with other movements in that it wishes to enact change from the current way of life. In contrast to past movements, however, the Rebelution does not seek to bring about some new change or way of life. Instead, the Rebelution seeks to return us to a lifestyle of responsibility and integrity, a lifestyle of a Biblical seeking after the Lord to help us to Do Hard Things.
In effect, the Rebelution is attempting to reverse the rebellion of movements both past and current that are trying to lead us down the wrong road, a road leading us into laziness, irresponsibility, and a destruction of our society.
Could it be said, then, that the Rebelution is the antithesis of rebellion, as it seeks to undo the countless years of damage brought about by our culture’s rebellion against God, the ultimate authority?
Excellent take! How true it is that we have fallen so far from God. I really love the idea of the Rebelution being the backwards motion of the rebellion we are all guilty of towards God. That is a great picture of our call to character. We are undoing the damage that we ourselves, and we as humans, have done. Very cool!
Aww… I… it…. WOW!
First of all, I would like to thank you, Alex and Brett, for maintaining a blog that makes its readers think about what their reading, form opinions about the world around them, and actually do something about it!
I feel very honored that you have chosen me as a runner-up, and I look forward to your future articles and challenges. May God continue to bless you and your ministry, as different of a ministry as it is. 😉
As a side note, I just noticed that the URLs are incorrect – the first lists it as a sub-directory of the Rebelution, and the second takes you to Zealous Endeavor. I know that it bugs me when I accidentally mis-link something on my own site, so I thought you might like to know that they were off.
And now, I really am going to get back to work. Heheh.
Hey Hannah! I’m really sorry about the messed up links. =P They’re fixed now.
Ah, I just checked back to this because I was filling out my forum application, and I realized that this links back to my old blog URL, which is no longer in existence. If you get a chance, would you mind updating it to http://www.homesteadblogger.com/affected so that it doesn’t take the reader to a dead link? I know, I know, this is the *second* time I’ve had to bug you about the links. I’m sorry about that.
Its great to find The Rebelution gaining so much notoriety amongst people all over the world… your post was well put, Hannah! How wonderful to have a website encouraging us to go against the current and fight for Truth.
The last paragraph sums it all up. Our job is to tear down the walls of rebellion and complacency Satan has built, to replace his lies with the undeniable truth of God’s Word!
Wow! thats a great story! I cant believe you only got runner up! But great job!
Extremely rated post. I be taught anything absolutely new on completely diverse blogs everyday. Deciding on one . stimulating to learn the paper content material from other writers and learn a bit something from their web-site. I’d prefer to apply particular of this content on my blog you happen to be mind. Natually I’ll give a hyperlink right here we’re at your internet-site. Recognize your sharing.
Hi there, just chanced upon your blog from your sister’s (Sarah). Is she still writing? I enjoyed reading her blog.